Supreme Court dismisses challenge to High Court order quashing order u/s 197 observing that AO should not be guided by the Revenue they might generate.
In a recent order Hon’ble Supreme Court declined to interfere with judgment of the High Court quashing order u/s 197 observing that passing similar orders year after year portrays an unhealthy and unwelcoming picture of the country’s bureaucracy on the one hand and gives pseudo satisfaction to the Revenue on the other.
ABCAUS Case Law Citation:
5262 (2026) (11) abacus.in SC
Important Case Laws relied upon by Parties:
Commissioner of Customs v. Canon India Private Limited [2025] 4 SCC 509
Central Council for Research in Ayurvedic Sciences v. Bikartan Das 2023 INSC 733
Hari Vishnu Kamath v. Syed Ahmad Ishaque & Ors. reported in [1954] 2 SCC 881
ZSCALER INC v. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax
Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner [1978] 1 SCC 405
In the instant case, the bone of contention was the action of the Assessing Officer (AO) in issuing a Certificate of lower deduction of tax u/s 197 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (the Act) prescribing 10% rate instead of certificate at nil rate as claimed by the applicant assessee.
The assessee was a foreign resident within the meaning of Article 4 of the relevant Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA), and was engaged in the business of operating Customer Relationship Management (CRM) offering applications and platforms including, sales, service, marketing and related products and services. These products were standardized and the customers can pick different combinations of products that are best suited for their requirements. The products helped the customers in generating reports and summaries of the data which is fed into the software by the clients themselves.
The assessee agitated the matter before the Hon’ble High Court and contended that AO had proceeded with pre-occupied mind and was swayed by the revenue collection rather than objectively going into the essence of transaction and considering legal position.
It was submitted that assessee did not have a place of business or any employee or any other sort of presence in India, nor did it had any Permanent Establishment (PE) in India, in terms of Article 5 of the DTAA.
It was further submitted that for a preceding Assessment Year though a certificate under Section 197 of the Act of 1961 was issued at 10% but pursuant to the order passed by Hon’ble High Court in the same assessee’s writ petition, a certificate of nil rate was issued. It was stated that thereafter the return of income was accepted as such and no tax was imposed or levied upon the petitioner.
It was also submitted that for the during immediately preceding Assessment Year, the AO again issued a certificate at 2% tax rate which was again set aside by the High Court and pursuant thereto a certificate of nil rate came to be issued.
It was submitted that though nature of assessee’s transactions and business remained the same during the FY under consideration but when the petitioner applied for a certificate under Section 197 the AO issued a certificate again requiring 10% deduction on the payments made without giving any reason as to how the transactions were liable for tax under the Act.
On the contrary, the Revenue submitted that Income Tax proceedings are separate for each assessment year and the Assessing Officer can take a different view in subsequent assessment years.
It was also contended that the signatory who had submitted the application under Section 197 of the Act to issue a nil rate certificate had a residential address of India, an Indian mobile number and had been uploading the documents regularly and even accessing the e-mails from India. Therefore, the assessee company should be construed to be a resident in India.
It was also submitted that while passing the earlier orders, the scheme of the Act, more particularly the part that relates to tax deduction at source given in Section 195 of the Act of 1961, vis-a-vis the provision given under Section 197 providing issuance of certificate of nil or lesser rate of tax was not placed before the High Court and therefore, those orders passed in ignorance of statutory scheme were per-incurium and thus not binding. In support of the contention the Revenue relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
The Hon’ble High Court observed that most of the arguments of the Revenue were not based on the facts as indicated in or arising out of the order of the AO.
The Hon’ble High Court opined that simply because a power of attorney has been given to a person residing in India and because all the required formations are done by such person, a company incorporated abroad or in any other country outside India, cannot be held to be a company resident in India within the meaning of Section 6(3) of the Act. For such purpose, one has to see the statutory provisions and according to which, the mandatory requirement is, that entire business of such company should be managed/controlled in India. No finding had been recorded by the competent officer nor did it emanate from the record that the petitioner company was resident in India or is having a PE in India.
The Hon’ble High Court noted that a simple look at the order would shows that it did not record any reason worth the name to justify deduction of tax at the rate of 10%. The approach of the AO had been arbitrary and propelled, rather impelled by the revenue considerations. In the over-enthusiasm of fetching extra revenue that too in the form of TDS, he even side-tracked two previous judgments of this Court, passed in assessee’s own case.
The Hon’ble High Court further observed that though it is correct that Income Tax Act proceedings are separate for each year but it is for the AO or the competent authority to bring on record difference in the fact-situation or some new fact must emerge which changes the residential status of the petitioner so that it can be inferred to have a PE in India or some change must take place which makes its receipts otherwise liable to be taxed under the provisions of the Act. In an appropriate case, the AO can take a detour from the view which had been taken by the High Court for a preceding year, but for that, he must record a concrete finding in relation to the change that has taken place during the relevant period, so also the fact that how the transactions being carried out by the petitioner are exigible to tax under the prevailing regime of the Income Tax Act.
The Hon’ble High Court held that mere use of expression ‘may’ given under Section 197 of the Act or purported discretion, the competent officer cannot be allowed to take whatever view he wishes to take. “Not to follow the binding precedents of the High Court cannot be countenanced in any manner and such approach renders the order a nullity”.
The Hon’ble High Court went on to observe that the present AO and the authorities dealing with the application under Section 197 of the Act are supposed to adopt a pragmatic and justice oriented approach-they should decide the applications in accordance with law, rather than being guided by the Revenue which they might generate, if the certificate(s) are issued at 10% rate or rate higher than ‘nil’.
The Hon’ble High Court observed that ease of doing business cannot be confined to slogans and Government policies; it has to percolate down in executive actions and quasi judicial orders. Passing similar orders year after year portrays an unhealthy and unwelcoming picture of the country’s bureaucracy on the one hand and gives pseudo satisfaction to the Revenue on the other.
As a result, the Hon’ble High Court quashed and set aside the order passed u/s 197 requiring deduction of tax at the rate of 10% and directed the AO to issue a certificate to the effect of nil rate of tax not only for the current AY but also for the subsequent years.
Not satisfied with the judgment of the High Court, the Department challenged it before the Hon’ble Supreme Court by way of filing a Special Leave Petition. However, the Apex Court dismissed the SLP observing that no error could be said to have been committed by the High Court in passing the impugned order.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court further expressed concern on the observation made by the High Court that scores of such petitions on this issue are pending before the High Court and directed that the same may now be taken up for final hearing and the issue may be decided once and for all.
Download Full Judgment Click Here >>
Notional rent based on the agreement can not be taxed when rent was subsequently reduced due to covid conditions -…
Mere CBDT Instructions cannot absolve individuals of their obligation to explain the source and nature of their gold holdings, even…
Empanelment of General Observers for ICSI Examinations December 2026 ICSI has invited interested members to enroll as General Observers for…
ITAT answers some important and inter-related issues relating to deduction u/s 80IA In a recent judgment, ITAT has dealt with…
Carry forward of loss can not be denied for belated return, it is only the set off in subsequent year…
Where sales are duly recorded in books and VAT returns, to treat it bogus sales, AO must bringing cogent adverse…