Income Tax

Penalty us 271C-Contumacious conduct of assessee necessary to be established before penalty for failure to deduct tax (TDS) can be imposed-Supreme Court

Penalty us 271C-Contumacious conduct of assessee necessary to be established before penalty for failure to deduct tax at source (TDS) can be imposed-Supreme Court

Case Details:
Civil Appeal No. 1704 of 2008
Commr. of Income Tax Delhi (Appellant)  vs. Bank of Nova Scotia (Respondent)
Date of Judgment: 07/01/2016
Coram: Justice Kurian Joseph and Justice Rohinton Fali Nariman
Non-Reportable

Brief Facts of the Case:
The dispute involved in this case was related to penalty u/s 271C for failure to deduct tax at source (TDS). The levy of the penalty was deleted by CIT(Appeals) and  the tribunal  also upheld the order of CIT(A). The ITAT held that,

“11..We have carefully considered the rival submissions. In the instant case we are not dealing with collection of tax u/s 201(1) or compensatory interest u/s 201(1A). The case of the assessee is that these amounts have already been paid so as to end dispute with Revenue. In the present appeals we are concerned with levy of penalty u/s 271-C for which it is necessary to establish that there was contumacious conduct on the part of the assessee. We find that on similar facts Hon’ble Delhi High Court have deleted levy of penalty u/s 271-C in the cae of M/s. Itochu Corporation, reported in 268 ITR 172 (Del) and in the case of CIT Vs. Mitsui & Company Ltd. reported in 272 ITR 545. Respectfully following the aforesaid judgments of Hon’ble Delhi High Court and the decision of the ITAT, Delhi in the case of Television Eighteen India Ltd., we allow the assessee’s appeal and cancel the penalty as levied u/s 271-C.”

Revenue agitated the matter before the Delhi High Court which rejected the appeal only on the ground that no substantial question of law arises in the matter.

The Hon’ble Supreme Court dismissed the Revenue’s appeal against the order of Delhi High Court and upheld that there was no substantial question of law. It further upheld the judgment of both CIT(A) and ITAT.

download full judgment

Share

Recent Posts

  • Income Tax

AO while issuing certificate u/s 197 should not be guided by the revenue generation

Supreme Court dismisses challenge to High Court order quashing order u/s 197 observing that AO should not be guided by…

2 days ago
  • Income Tax

Notional rent can not be taxed when rent was reduced due to covid conditions – ITAT

Notional rent based on the agreement can not be taxed when rent was subsequently reduced due to covid conditions -…

2 days ago
  • Prevention of Corruption Act

CBDT Instruction can not absolve persons to explain source of gold within limits specified – SC

Mere CBDT Instructions cannot absolve individuals of their obligation to explain the source and nature of their gold holdings, even…

1 week ago
  • ICSI

Empanelment of General Observers for ICSI Examinations December 2026. Last date 16.11.2026

Empanelment of General Observers for ICSI Examinations December 2026 ICSI has invited interested members to enroll as General Observers for…

1 week ago
  • Income Tax

ITAT address some important issues relating to deduction u/s 80IA

ITAT answers some important and inter-related issues relating to deduction u/s 80IA In a recent judgment, ITAT has dealt with…

1 week ago
  • Income Tax

Mere carry forward of loss can not be denied for belated return – ITAT

Carry forward of loss can not be denied for belated return, it is only the set off in subsequent year…

2 weeks ago