Income Tax

Revision under section 263 is not to set aside merely unfavourable orders and bring to tax some more money to the treasury-ITAT

In a recent judgment, ITAT Delhi has interpreted the objective and scope of invoking revisionary powers of Commissioner of Income Tax (CIT) under section 263 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 as under:

  1. The provisions of section 263 cannot be invoked to correct each and every type of mistake or error committed by the AO.
  2. The ambit of interference under section 263 is not to set aside merely unfavourable orders and bring to tax some more money to the treasury.
  3. The section is not enacted to get a sheer escapement of revenue which is taken care of in other provisions of the Act.
  4. Prejudice that is contemplated under section 263 is the prejudice to the income-tax administration as a whole.
  5. Section 263 is to be invoked not as a jurisdictional corrective or as a review of a subordinate’s order in exercise of the supervisory power.
  6. Section 263 is to be invoked and employed only for setting right distortions and prejudices to the revenue, which is a unique conception, which is to be understood in the context of and in the interests of the Revenue administration. 

Case Law Details:
I.T.A .No.-3007/Del/2014 ASSESSMENT YEAR-2009-10
Modicare Limited vs CIT
date of Judgment: 19/04/2016

download full judgment

Share

Recent Posts

  • Income Tax

Date of digital signature and issue determines date of a notice u/s 148 of Income Tax Act

Date of digital signature and issuance determines the date of a notice u/s148 of the Income Tax Act - ITAT…

2 days ago
  • DGFT

DGFT authorises IACCIA to issue Certificate of Origin (Non- Preferential)

DGFT authorises IACCIA to issue Certificate of Origin (Non- Preferential) w.e.f. 9th January 2026 In exercise of powers conferred under…

2 days ago
  • Income Tax

Net profit rate may not have variation commensurate to increase of turnover

Net profit rate may not per se experience variation commensurate to the increase of turnover. In a recent judgment, Allahabad…

2 days ago
  • Excise/Custom

Mushroom growing apparatus cannot be classified as ‘agricultural machinery’

Mushroom growing apparatus cannot be classified as ‘agricultural machinery’ under Customs Tariff Heading 8436. In a recent judgment, Hon'ble Supreme…

2 days ago
  • negotiable instrument act

Statutory presumption attached to issuance of a cheque to be accorded due weight – SC

Statutory presumption attached to issuance of a cheque, being one made in discharge of a legally enforceable debt or liability,…

3 days ago
  • tender

Highest bid can’t be discarded on mere expectation of even more higher bid

Merely because the authority conducting auction expects higher bid than the highest bidder is no reason to discard the highest…

3 days ago