Supreme Court

5 judge Bench of SC recalls its 2013 controversial judgment which quashed National Eligibility Entrance Test as unconstitutional

The Supreme Court recalls its judgment delivered on 28-07-2013 delivered by a three judge Bench which had quashed the National Eligibility Entrance Test as unconstitutional. The judgment was alleged as leaked even before it was pronounced and had created a lot of controversies.

A 5-judge Bench headed by Justice Anil Dave allowed the review petitions and recalled the 2013 while directing that the matter be heard afresh. It is notable that in the 2013 judgment, it was Justice Dave who had given a dissenting opinion against the majority opinion by the then Chief Justice of India , Altamas Kabir. 

The Apex Court did not state detailed reasons but mentioned that the majority view had not been taken into consideration some binding precedents and there was no discussion among the members of the Bench before pronouncement of the judgment.

Case Details:
Review Petition (C)NOS.2159-2268 OF 2013  and Review Petition (C) NOS.2048-2157 OF 2013
Medical Council of India (Petitioner) vs. Christian Medical College Vellore & Ors (Respondents)
Date of Judgment: 11/04/2016

download full judgment

 

Share

Recent Posts

  • Income Tax

Penalty u/s 271B is not attracted where books of account not maintained – ITAT Allahabad

Penalty u/s 271B is not attracted in a case where books of account have not been maintained In a recent…

13 hours ago
  • Empanelment

NALCO invites RFP for empanelment of CA Firms for verification of Stores/Spares & movable assets

NALCO invites RFP for empanelment of Chartered Accountant Firms for verification of Stores/Spares and movable assets.  NALCO has invited Request…

15 hours ago
  • RBI

Sending or bringing currency of Nepal and Bhutan – RBI revises regulations

Sending or bringing currency of Nepal and Bhutan - RBI revises exiting regulations  RBI has notified the Foreign Exchange Management…

15 hours ago
  • Excise/Custom

Manufacturing without aid of power. Entire process though by distinct units to be seen – SC

Entire manufacturing process though by distinct units relevant for exemption from excise duty on account of manufacture without aid of…

16 hours ago
  • Income Tax

Delay in filing Form 10B condoned as failure was in 1st year of operation of Trust

High Court condoned delay in filing Form 10B as the failure was in the 1st Year of operation of the…

18 hours ago
  • Income Tax

Penalty u/s 270A quashed for no satisfaction on what was under reporting & misreporting by assessee

Penalty u/s 270A quashed as there was no satisfaction in the penalty order on what exactly was under reporting of…

21 hours ago