Income Tax

Addition based on judicial precedence unsustainable without addressing factual inadequacies – ITAT

Addition based on judicial precedence in other cases unsustainable without first addressing the factual inadequacy of assessee’s explanation – ITAT

 

ABCAUS Case Law Citation:
ABCAUS 2112 (2017) (11) ITAT

The Challenge/Grievance:
The appellant assessee had challenged the correctness of the order passed by CIT(A) confirming the additions on account of unexplained deposits.

 Brief Facts of the Case:
The assessee company, during the relevant year, had received unsecured loans from its directors. The company was required to establish the identity, creditworthiness and genuineness of the transaction. The assessee in response thereto admittedly filed copies of the bank statement, copy of income tax returns and confirmations of the creditors. However the Assessing Officer (AO) made an addition of Rs. 2.50 lakhs holding that the amounts were not explained.

The addition was sustained by the CIT-Appeals.

Before the Tribunal, the assessee submitted that the explanation advanced had not been rebutted or negatively commented upon by the Assessing Officer who mechanically made the addition. It was contended that the onus caste upon the assessee stood discharged.

It was argued that the action of the AO in placing reliance on various decisions in different cases without rebutting the evidence submitted was an incorrect approach.

Observations made by the Tribunal:
The ITAT opined that once the assessee had given the copies of bank statements, copies of income tax returns and also filed confirmations of the creditors wherein no defect had been pointed out by the tax authorities, the addition relying upon judicial precedence in different cases without first addressing the factual inadequacy of assessee’s explanation cannot be sustained.

Decision/ Conclusion/Held:
The addition was directed to be deleted. 

Download Full Judgment

Share

Recent Posts

  • GST

Amendment proposed in section 16(2) of GST Act to resolve difficulties in availing ITC credit

Amendment proposed in section 16(2) of GST Act to resolve difficulties faced by the bona fide recipients in availing ITC…

14 hours ago
  • Income Tax

Traffic management hub is an essential public function and charitable activity u/s 11 – ITAT

Operation and maintenance of traffic management hub is an essential public function and hence charitable activity u/s 11 of the…

1 day ago
  • Income Tax

AO while issuing certificate u/s 197 should not be guided by the revenue generation

Supreme Court dismisses challenge to High Court order quashing order u/s 197 observing that AO should not be guided by…

4 days ago
  • Income Tax

Notional rent can not be taxed when rent was reduced due to covid conditions – ITAT

Notional rent based on the agreement can not be taxed when rent was subsequently reduced due to covid conditions -…

4 days ago
  • Prevention of Corruption Act

CBDT Instruction can not absolve persons to explain source of gold within limits specified – SC

Mere CBDT Instructions cannot absolve individuals of their obligation to explain the source and nature of their gold holdings, even…

1 week ago
  • ICSI

Empanelment of General Observers for ICSI Examinations December 2026. Last date 16.11.2026

Empanelment of General Observers for ICSI Examinations December 2026 ICSI has invited interested members to enroll as General Observers for…

2 weeks ago