Regime of service tax can not be invoked if assessee had regularly paid amount of VAT liability towards the same transaction
ABCAUS Case Law Citation
ABCAUS 3568 (2022) (01) SC
The assessee was engaged in conversion of analog cinema content into digital format. The movies were exhibited in theaters using Digital Cinema equipment leased by the assessee to theater owners for which he charged and paid VAT on lease rent.
Based on audit observation the assessee was issued show cause notice demanding service tax on the ground that from as per the agreement with the clients, the legal right of possession and effective control of the Digital Cinema Equipments had not been transferred to the lessee and total control over the equipment remained with Appellant and as such the activity undertaken by the Appellant falls under the category of “supply of tangible goods for use” as defined under Section 65(105)(zzzz) of the Finance Act, 1994. Following the SCN, the demand was confirmed.
The matter travelled to CESTAT which set aside the demand.
The Commissioner of Service Tax filed an appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court challenging the order of the Tribunal.
The assessee contended that the Appeal was devoid of merits as he had already paid VAT on the same transaction and for which reason, it was not open to invoke regime of service tax in respect of the same transaction.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court opined that since the assessee had regularly paid the amount towards VAT liability in respect of the subject goods during the relevant period, the question of claiming service tax thereon did not arise.
Accordingly, the civil appeal was dismissed.
Download Full Judgment Click Here >>
- Revisionary order purportedly passed earlier but dispatched after written Submissions quashed
- Assessment u/s 147 based on seized material found during search of third party void ab-initio
- TDS deductors given relief for non deduction of TDS at higher rate for inoperative PANs
- Reassessment order quashed due to error in personal hearing video conferencing link
- Assessee may show that it was over assessed under erroneous impression of law
